Apakah Idul Fitri di Arab Saudi harus menjadi patokan bagi negara lain?

Majlis al-Qada’ in Saudi Arabia has announced that Eidul Fitr will be on 
Tuesday, August 30, 2011.



Sighting Reports

The earliest sighting of the new crescent was on xxxxxxx.
Monday, 29 August 2011:

Australia: Not Seen: Engr Manzoor A Mian (MCW member) from Melbourne, VIC reported: Shawal Crescent is not sighted in Australia today Monday 29/8/11.

China: Not Seen, but Eid Declared: Dr. Musa·Minhai (MCW member) from Linxia, Gansu Province reported: I and some Imams of Mosque did not sight the hilal- for Shawwal by the naked eye and binocular on Monday, 29 August 2011 at Linxia city in China. There was not cloud at the horizon. Sky is very very clear. But one and some peoples declared that they sighted the hilal by the naked at other place in Llinxia. So Imams of many Mosques have decided the first day of Shawwal is 30 August 2011 (Tuesday).

France: Not Seen, but Eid declared: Rida Roty (MCW member) from Caen (Normandie) reported: France: Official Announcement Eid el Fitr: Tuesday 30 August. See the link http://www.saphirnews.com/L-Aid-el-F...ce_a13100.html

India: Not Seen: Mohammed Mohsin Khan (MCW member) from Mumbai reported: Today Monday 29 August 2011 / 28 Ramadaan 1432 in India. Here in Mumbai Sunset was at 06:56 pm LT and Moonset was at 06:57 pm LT . So there was only 1 min difference . It was certain that the crescent would not be sighted anywhere in India today . I tried to sight the moon due to the 29th day according to the Ummul Qura calendar but Shawwaal crescent has not been sighted in India.

Indonesia: Not Seen: AR Sugeng Riyadi (MCW member) from Surakarta, Java reported: On Monday, August 29, 2011, New Crescent of Shawwal 1432 AH was NOT SEEN, from any location in Indonesia. There are two reports from Jepara and Cakung that Hilal of Syawwal was SEEN, but the report was rejected. Religious Affairs Ministry of Indonesia decided that 1 Shawwal 1432 AH will be on Wednesday, August 31, 2011.

New Zealand: Not seen: Sheikh Mohammad Amir, for Hilal Committee of New Zealand reported: On behalf of the Hilal Committee, I wish to inform that the new moon for Shawaal has not been sighted today. Therefore, the Hilal Committee would like to announce that we will complete 30 days of fasting tomorrow and Eid will be observed all over New Zealand on Wednesday, 31st August 2011.

Philippines: Eid declared: Dr. Mansoor Limba (MCW member) from Cotabato City reported: ‘Id al-Fitr declared amidst cloudy weather and occasional rain shower, Cotabato City-based Darul Ifta declared tomorrow (Tuesday/August 30, 2011) as ‘Id al-Fitr.

Turkey: Not Seen (but Officially announced): Muhammed Cevad Turan from Intanbul reported: Shawwal Crescent is not sighted in Istanbul, Turkey as expected. However Turkish Religious Affairs Office officially declareted that 30th of August is 1th of Shawwal (Eid-fitr) according to calculations. Now it is 21:25 and we still waiting for South America's reports to declare Eid-fitr.





OFFICIAL 1st Day of Shawwal in Different Countries

August 30, 2011 (Tuesday):

China (Local sighting that we believe erroneous)
Denmark (Follow Saudi)
France (Official Announcement)
Jordan (Follow Saudi)
Kazakhstan (Follow Saudi)
Kuwait (Follow Saudi)
Kyrgyzstan (Follow Saudi)
Lebanon (Follow Saudi)
Libya (Calculations)
Luxembourg (Follow Saudi)
Malaysia (Calculations)
Netherlands (Follow Saudi)
Palestine (Follow Saudi)
Philippines (Follow Saudi)
Qatar (Follow Saudi)
Saudi Arabia (sighting - Official Announcement)
Sudan (Follow Saudi)
Sweden (Follow Saudi)
Syria (Follow Saudi)
UAE (Follow Saudi)
Tadjikistan (Follow Saudi)
Taiwan (Follow Saudi)
Turkey (Follow Saudi)
Turkmenistan (Follow Saudi)
USA (Calculations) [FCNA, ISNA]
Uzbekistan (Follow Saudi)
Yemen (Follow Saudi)

------------

Para Astronom bersikekeuh bahwa HILAL belum terlihat, termasuk astronom di Arab Saudi. Tapi Pemerintah Arab Saudi yang jadi anutan banyak negara di dunia, telah menetapkan Lebaran tanggal 30 Agustus.


--------------


Menurut hasil Bahtsul Matsail di PP Hasan Genggong Probolinggo tahun 1989 :

Masalah

Apakah hasil ru’yah di suatu tempat mengikat seluruh Indonesia, sedang waktunya terbagi, WIB, WITA, WIT. Berapa kilometer batas mutlak dari tempat ru’yat  ke timur?

Jawab :

a.	Mengenai mengikat dan tidaknya terdapat khilaf di antara ulama

b.	Batas mutlak dari tempat ru’yah ke timur + 120 Km.

Dasar Pengambilan :

a.	Syarwani Juz III 282

b.	Majmu’ Juz VI hal. 273

c.	Bughyatul Mustarsydin hal. 108

مسئلة ى ) اذا ثبت الهلال ببلد عم الحكم جميع البلدان التى تحت حكم حاكم بلد الرؤية وان تباعدت ان) تحدت المطالع والالم يجب صوم ولافطر مطلقا وان تحد الحاكم ولو اتفق المطلع ولم يكن للحاكم ولاية لم يجب الا على من وقع فى قلبه صدق الحاكم وسجب ايضا ببلوغ الخبر بالرؤية فى حق من بلغة متواترا او مستفيضا والتواتر ما اخبر به جمع يمتنع تواطؤهم على الكذب عن امر محسوس ولا يشترط اسلامهم ولا عدالتهم والمستفيض ماشاع بين الناس مستندا لاصل. اهـ. بغية المسترشدين الصحفة 108